……..considered social anthropology as similar to comparative sociology? | Sociology for CUET by Vikash Ranjan | Sociology Guru

Comparative Sociology

Question: ……..considered social anthropology as similar to comparative sociology?

  1. Malinowski
  2. Weber
  3. Radcliffe-Brown
  4. Tylor

Answer: (3)

Theoretical Crossroads: Radcliffe-Brown’s Relationship with Functionalism

The realm of social anthropology has been marked by theoretical debates and intellectual crosscurrents, with scholars shaping and reshaping the landscape of the discipline. A pivotal figure in this intellectual tapestry is A.R. Radcliffe-Brown, whose relationship with functionalism, particularly with its iconic representative Bronislaw Malinowski, adds a layer of complexity to the narrative of social anthropological thought. This exploration delves into the historical and theoretical dimensions of Radcliffe-Brown’s engagement with functionalism, aiming to unravel the nuances of their theoretical conflict and the broader implications it holds for social anthropology.

Functionalism as the Theoretical Framework:

Functionalism, a dominant paradigm in early social anthropology, sought to understand societies by examining the functions of their constituent elements. Bronislaw Malinowski, a prominent proponent of functionalism, emphasized the functional interdependence of various cultural practices and institutions within a society. His ethnographic work, particularly in the Trobriand Islands, laid the foundation for functionalist thought by focusing on the practical functions of customs and rituals in maintaining societal equilibrium.

Radcliffe-Brown’s Entry into the Theoretical Arena:

A.R. Radcliffe-Brown, an influential figure in structural-functionalism, entered the theoretical arena against the backdrop of Malinowski’s functionalism. While sharing certain foundational ideas, Radcliffe-Brown’s approach diverged from Malinowski’s emphasis on the individual and psychological aspects. Radcliffe-Brown’s structural-functionalism shifted the focus to social structures and their interrelated functions, advocating for a more holistic analysis of societies.

Polemics and Polemics:

The later polemics between Radcliffe-Brown and Malinowski offer a glimpse into their theoretical divergence. Radcliffe-Brown, while distancing himself from functionalism, did not diminish the significance of Malinowski’s contributions. The conflict, as revealed in Radcliffe-Brown’s utterances, may seem paradoxical given the long-standing familiarity both scholars had with each other’s positions. However, understanding this conflict requires an exploration of the theoretical nuances and evolving perspectives within the realm of functionalism.

Functional Analysis as a Basic Analytical Tool:

Contrary to the apparent distancing from functionalism, Radcliffe-Brown viewed functional analysis as a fundamental component of social science. The skepticism in his later works might be seen as a critique or refinement rather than an outright rejection. His engagement with functionalism was not merely polemical but also reflected a nuanced recognition of its role in understanding social phenomena. Functional analysis, according to Radcliffe-Brown, was integral to the broader analytical toolkit of social science.

The Significance of Malinowski’s Work:

While Radcliffe-Brown expressed skepticism in later writings, he did not undermine the significance of Malinowski’s work. Malinowski’s contributions, particularly his focus on the practical functions of customs and rituals, were acknowledged. Radcliffe-Brown recognized the value of functionalism in shedding light on the interconnectedness of cultural elements, albeit with a shift in emphasis from the individual to broader social structures.

Examples of Interpretation:

The relationship between Radcliffe-Brown and functionalism wasn’t one-dimensional. There were instances where Radcliffe-Brown assumed the role of an interpreter for the functionalist position. This dual role – a critic and interpreter – reveals a complex engagement with functionalism. Radcliffe-Brown’s interpretation of functionalism suggests a nuanced understanding that transcends mere theoretical opposition.

Conclusion: Navigating Theoretical Waters:

In conclusion, Radcliffe-Brown’s relationship with functionalism is characterized by intellectual complexities, where theoretical conflicts coexist with recognition of the paradigm’s value. While later polemics may give the impression of a stark divide, a closer examination reveals a more intricate interplay of ideas. Radcliffe-Brown’s structural-functionalism, with its emphasis on social structures and their functions, represents a departure from Malinowski’s individual-centered functionalism.

The skepticism expressed in later works should be viewed as a testament to the dynamic nature of theoretical discourses within social anthropology. Radcliffe-Brown’s dual role as a critic and interpreter exemplifies the multifaceted nature of scholarly engagements. This nuanced understanding of Radcliffe-Brown’s relationship with functionalism enriches our comprehension of the intellectual currents that have shaped the discipline, offering a glimpse into the theoretical waters navigated by pioneering figures in social anthropology.


Take a Quick Sociology Quiz to measure your Performance


Frequently Asked Questions:

1. Question: Define the term “ethnic movement” and provide an example from India.

Answer: An ethnic movement refers to a collective effort by a group sharing common cultural, linguistic, or religious traits, seeking to assert their identity and rights; an example from India is the Khalistan Movement in Punjab.

2. Question: Identify the main objectives behind the Gorkhaland ethnic movement.

Answer: The Gorkhaland ethnic movement primarily seeks to establish a separate state for India’s Nepali-speaking population in the Darjeeling region, advocating for linguistic and cultural recognition and political autonomy.

3. Question: What was the Operation Blue Star, and which ethnic movement was it related to?
Answer: Operation Blue Star was a military action in 1984, aiming to remove Sikh militants hiding in the Golden Temple in Amritsar; it is related to the Khalistan movement, which sought a separate Sikh country.

4. Question: Mention a critical factor that triggered the emergence of ethnic movements in India, as discussed by Dipankar Gupta.
Answer: Dipankar Gupta emphasized that ethnicity is fundamentally a political process, wherein caste and religion, the key components of identity formation, are politicized by leaders for vested interests.

5. Question: What were the primary reasons for the Assam Ethnicity conflicts involving Bodo tribals and Bengali Muslim settlers?
Answer: The Assam Ethnicity conflicts primarily stemmed from issues related to immigration, land rights, and resource allocation, leading to clashes, riots, and evolving relationships among indigenous communities to address challenges.

6. Question: Briefly describe the role of the Dravidian Movement in terms of caste and societal structure.
Answer: The Dravidian Movement, led notably by E.V. Ramasamy, aimed to establish an egalitarian society, focusing on anti-Brahmanism and advocating for equal rights for backward castes, while also introducing reforms like self-respect marriages.

7. Question: Name the prominent ethnic movements in North-East India and specify one common objective.
Answer: Prominent ethnic movements in North-East India include the Nagas’ and Mizos’ struggles; a common objective was to gain autonomy and recognition for their distinct tribal identities and cultural uniqueness.

8. Question: What is the key argument of Gail Omveldt regarding traditional Indian society and multiculturalism?
Answer: Gail Omveldt opposed romanticizing traditional Indian society, arguing that hierarchy has always dominated it and dismissing the notion that multiculturalism is an intrinsic feature of Indian society as a myth.

9. Question: Briefly explain the social hierarchy factor as a contributing element to ethnic movements as suggested by Olzak.
Answer: Olzak suggests that the construction of hierarchies among ethnic communities, which often leads to the suppression of one group by another, is a key factor that can instigate social and ethnic movements.

10. Question: Identify one consequence of the unequal economic development factor within the context of ethnic movements in India.
Answer: One consequence of unequal economic development is the marginalization and underdevelopment of certain groups, leading to feelings of alienation and sometimes initiating ethnic movements as these groups strive for equality and recognition.

To master these intricacies and fare well in the Sociology Syllabus, aspiring sociologists might benefit from guidance by the Best Sociology Teacher and participation in the Best Sociology Coaching. These avenues provide comprehensive assistance, ensuring a solid understanding of sociology’s diverse methodologies and techniques.


Why Vikash Ranjan’s Classes for Sociology?


Proper guidance and assistance are required to learn the skill of interlinking current happenings with the conventional topics. VIKASH RANJAN SIR at SOCIOLOGY GURU guides students according to the Recent Trends, making him the Best Sociology Teacher for Sociology.

At Sociology Guru, the Best Sociology Coaching platform, we not only provide the best study material and applied classes for Sociology but also conduct regular assignments and class tests to assess candidates’ writing skills and understanding of the subject.

Choose The Best Sociology Teacher for your Preparation?


To master these intricacies and fare well in the Sociology Syllabus, aspiring sociologists might benefit from guidance by the Best Sociology Teacher and participation in the Best Sociology Coaching. These avenues provide comprehensive assistance, ensuring a solid understanding of sociology’s diverse methodologies and techniques. Sociology, Social theory, Best Sociology Teacher, Best Sociology Coaching, Sociology Syllabus.

Best Sociology Teacher, Sociology Syllabus, Sociology, Sociology Coaching, Best Sociology Coaching, Best Sociology Teacher, Sociology Course, Sociology Teacher, Sociology Foundation, Sociology Foundation Course, Sociology CUET, Sociology for IAS, Sociology for UPSC, Sociology for BPSC, Sociology for UGC NET, Sociology for JPSC,

Follow us :




KEYWORD: -Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, Comparative Sociology, MA CUET SOCIOLOGY


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top